Beef/Lamb · Burgers and Sandwiches · Recipes

Deli-Style Corned Beef Sandwich

corned beef sandwich, deli

There is a deli just outside of Denver that Mister and I absolutely love to eat at when we’re in the area.  They are as Jewish as a Jewish deli can get.  They have matzo ball soup, challah bread, lox, latkes, knish, pastrami … you name it and they have it.  This particular deli also has the best corned beef sandwiches I have ever wrapped my teeth around!  Unfortunately, we live over an hour away from Denver, so if we’re not heading down there for something else, it really is a bit of a drive.  I had a mean hankering for one of these babies so I decided to make my own version at home.

At the deli, you get a huge pile of thinly sliced corned beef and swiss between two slices of their homemade bread.  Mustard, relish and horseradish are served on the side.  I put spicy ground mustard, swiss and dill pickles on my sandwiches.  My corned beef wasn’t sliced as thin as the deli’s but it tasted just as amazing as theirs.

corned beef sandwich, deli, swiss

I realized (the next day) that the leftover corned beef was much easier to slice than the hot corned beef was.  If you have the time, make the corned beef the night before you want to make sandwiches.  Once the meat is cooled, you can easily cut thin slices with a sharp knife.  Otherwise, just do the best you can with what you have.  Some of it fell apart while I was cutting it, but hey, it all goes in the same place anyway, right?

Deli-Style Corned Beef Sandwich

Rating: 51

Prep Time: 15 minutes

Cook Time: 4 hours

Total Time: 4 hours, 15 minutes

Yields: About 4 sandwiches

Deli-Style Corned Beef Sandwich


  • 2-3 pounds of uncooked corned beef (tip or flat)
  • 1 Tablespoon pickling spice (you'll sometimes get a packet of this included with your beef)
  • 1/2 yellow onion, cut in half
  • Slices of baby swiss
  • Spicy stone ground mustard
  • Dill pickles, thinly sliced
  • Rye bread


  1. Place the corned beef, spices and onion into a crock pot. Add enough water to cover the beef by an inch. Set the crock pot for high and cook for an hour. After an hour, lower to low heat. Cook for 2-3 more hours, or until the corned beef is almost fall apart tender.
  2. Carefully remove the beef to a cutting board and remove all remnants of pickling spice. Allow to cool for 10 minutes. Take a spoon and scrape any fat off of the meat, then cut the beef into thin slices (as best as you can) against the grain. If you cooked the corned beef to complete fall apart tenderness, you can skip this step and just break up the beef a bit. Note: Slicing is much easier to do after you've cooled your beef and put it into the fridge. You can always save the slicing for later.
  3. To build your sandwich: Place a thin layer of stone ground mustard on a slice of rye bread, and top with enough thin slices of pickle to cover most of the sandwich's surface area. Add a good-sized pile of corned beef, a slice of swiss and another piece of bread. Devour.

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...

4 thoughts on “Deli-Style Corned Beef Sandwich

  1. Sound delish…If, for some reason, you ever find yourself on the south side of Indy near where I grew up, visit Shapiro’s deli. Freakin amazing Reubens.

        1. If I ever make it to Ft. Collins, I’ll probably be too drunk to eat anything except delicious craft beers. But I’ll try to keep this place in mind 😉

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.